Fantasy Hockey Goaltending Deep Dive: 2025 Season Review & Future Projections

Comprehensive analysis of NHL goalie performance in fantasy hockey with expert predictions for the 2025-26 season, including breakout candidates and strategy tips.

The Changing Landscape of Fantasy Goaltending

Over the past decade, we've witnessed a dramatic shift in fantasy hockey goaltending value. Where once netminders dominated the upper echelons of fantasy rankings, recent seasons have seen a significant decline in their overall impact - but signs point to a potential resurgence.

Historical Perspective:

  • 2014-15 Season: 7 of top 10 fantasy players were goalies
  • 2017-18 Season: 6 of top 10 were netminders
  • 2019-20 Season: Major decline with only 2 top-10 goalies
  • 2023-24 Season: Rock bottom with zero goalies in top 10

Current Season Trends

The 2024-25 campaign represents a slight rebound for fantasy goalies:

  • A goaltender has reclaimed the #1 overall fantasy spot
  • Two netminders projected to finish top-10 (matching 2019-20 numbers)
  • Nine goalies likely to land in top 100 fantasy players

Key Factors Influencing Performance:

  1. Timeshares: Increased crease splitting reduces individual value
  2. Age Fluctuations: Top-10 goalie age dropped to 27.6 (2022-23) before rebounding to 30.3
  3. Emerging Talent: New generation of young goalies developing

Team-by-Team Fantasy Outlook

Top Contenders:

  • Winnipeg Jets: Connor Hellebuyck (#1 fantasy goalie) continues to dominate
  • Tampa Bay Lightning: Andrei Vasilevskiy remains elite (#2 ranked)
  • Minnesota Wild: Filip Gustavsson emerging as top-3 option

Rising Stars:

  • Calgary Flames: Dustin Wolf (#10 among goalies) shows great promise
  • Carolina Hurricanes: Pyotr Kochetkov ready for breakout season
  • Montreal Canadiens: Sam Montembeault positioned for major improvement

Buy-Low Candidates:

  • New York Rangers: Igor Shesterkin likely to rebound after "down" year
  • New Jersey Devils: Jacob Markstrom with top-10 potential if healthy
  • Los Angeles Kings: Darcy Kuemper proving age is just a number

Future Projections for 2025-26

We're likely seeing the beginning of a goaltending renaissance:

  • Current sub-30 goalies will mature with more experience
  • Several top prospects (Yaroslav Askarov, Jesper Wallstedt) near NHL-ready
  • Improved defensive systems across league could boost goalie stats

Draft Strategy Recommendations:

  1. Early Rounds: Target proven workhorses (Hellebuyck, Vasilevskiy)
  2. Mid Rounds: Take shots on young talent (Wolf, Kochetkov)
  3. Late Rounds: Consider high-upside backups on good teams

Pro Tip: Monitor playoff performances as they may significantly alter 2025-26 draft stocks for many goalies.

What to Read Next

The Ultimate NHL Draft Legends: Best Picks from Slot 1 to 224
NHL

The Ultimate NHL Draft Legends: Best Picks from Slot 1 to 224

Discover the greatest NHL draft picks from every slot, analyzing players from 1967 to 2025. From Mario Lemieux to Wayne Simmonds, explore the legends who shaped hockey history.

Team USA's Quest for Olympic Gold: A New Era in Men's Hockey
NHL

Team USA's Quest for Olympic Gold: A New Era in Men's Hockey

Team USA aims to clinch their first Olympic gold in men's hockey since 1980, leveraging a golden generation of NHL stars and a revamped strategy.

Hockey Diversity Alliance: 5 Years of Impact, Challenges, and Future Goals
NHL

Hockey Diversity Alliance: 5 Years of Impact, Challenges, and Future Goals

Celebrating 5 years of the Hockey Diversity Alliance, exploring its impact on hockey diversity, challenges faced, and future goals for inclusive sports.

NHL Teams Embrace Taylor Swift's New Album 'The Life of a Showgirl' in Creative Social Media Tributes
NHL

NHL Teams Embrace Taylor Swift's New Album 'The Life of a Showgirl' in Creative Social Media Tributes

NHL teams creatively celebrate Taylor Swift's new album 'The Life of a Showgirl' with unique social media posts, blending pop culture and hockey.

Buffalo Sabres Secure Conor Timmins with a Two-Year Deal, Avoid Arbitration
NHL

Buffalo Sabres Secure Conor Timmins with a Two-Year Deal, Avoid Arbitration

The Buffalo Sabres have successfully avoided salary arbitration by signing defenseman Conor Timmins to a two-year contract worth $4.4 million.

Jackson Blake Secures Future with Carolina Hurricanes: A Deep Dive into the $45M Deal
NHL

Jackson Blake Secures Future with Carolina Hurricanes: A Deep Dive into the $45M Deal

Jackson Blake signs a monumental $45 million, 8-year contract with the Carolina Hurricanes, highlighting his promising future in the NHL.

Arvid Soderblom Secures Future with Blackhawks: A Deep Dive into the Goaltender's New Contract
NHL

Arvid Soderblom Secures Future with Blackhawks: A Deep Dive into the Goaltender's New Contract

Explore the details of Arvid Soderblom's new two-year contract with the Chicago Blackhawks and its impact on the team's future.

NFL Stars Kaepernick and Lynch Champion Diversity in Hockey with Toronto Road Hockey Tournament
NHL

NFL Stars Kaepernick and Lynch Champion Diversity in Hockey with Toronto Road Hockey Tournament

Former NFL players Colin Kaepernick and Marshawn Lynch collaborate with the Hockey Diversity Alliance to promote inclusivity in hockey through a free road hockey tournament in Toronto.

Nicklas Backstrom Returns to Hockey: A New Chapter with Brynas IF in Sweden
NHL

Nicklas Backstrom Returns to Hockey: A New Chapter with Brynas IF in Sweden

After overcoming a persistent hip injury, Nicklas Backstrom resumes his hockey career with Brynas IF in Sweden, marking a new chapter in his storied journey.

From Texas to Pennsylvania: The Ultimate NHL Trivia Challenge
NHL

From Texas to Pennsylvania: The Ultimate NHL Trivia Challenge

Test your NHL knowledge with our ultimate trivia quiz spanning from Texas to Pennsylvania. Can you ace it?

Tkachuk Brothers: From NHL Glory to Olympic Dreams and Beyond
NHL

Tkachuk Brothers: From NHL Glory to Olympic Dreams and Beyond

Matthew and Brady Tkachuk discuss their NHL success, Olympic aspirations, and the impact of their father on their careers.

Devon Levi Secures Future with Buffalo Sabres: A Detailed Look at His New 2-Year Contract
NHL

Devon Levi Secures Future with Buffalo Sabres: A Detailed Look at His New 2-Year Contract

Explore the details of Devon Levi's new 2-year, $1.625M contract with the Buffalo Sabres, including his performance stats and future prospects.

KeyBank Center Secures Decade-Long Naming Rights Deal with Buffalo Sabres
NHL

KeyBank Center Secures Decade-Long Naming Rights Deal with Buffalo Sabres

The Buffalo Sabres and KeyBank Center announce a 10-year naming rights extension, solidifying their partnership until 2035-36.

Gaudreau Family 5K Raises $500K for Accessible Playground: A Legacy of Love and Community Support
NHL

Gaudreau Family 5K Raises $500K for Accessible Playground: A Legacy of Love and Community Support

The Gaudreau Family 5K raised over $500,000 for an accessible playground at Archbishop Damiano School, honoring the legacy of John and Matthew Gaudreau.

Keith Tkachuk: From NHL Legend to Proud Hockey Dad
NHL

Keith Tkachuk: From NHL Legend to Proud Hockey Dad

Keith Tkachuk reflects on his sons' NHL success, the Panthers' Stanley Cup win, and his thoughts on the Hockey Hall of Fame.

Load More

We use essential cookies to make our site work. With your consent, we may also use non-essential cookies to improve user experience and analyze website traffic. By clicking "Accept," you agree to our website's cookie use as described in our Cookie Policy.